Assessing the progress of third-year head coaches
The last two coaching change cycles have been relatively quiet by recent standards, and that’s perhaps in part due to the frenzy that athletics directors and university presidents found themselves in during the final weeks of 2012 and the first weeks of 2013. Twenty-nine coaches hired prior to the 2013 season will enter their third seasons this fall – nearly as many as the two following classes combined.
As you’ll see below, the first two seasons for the 29 members of the 2013 class have followed many different paths. Some have been handed the keys to a Maserati, others are trying to build a new car from spare parts, and still others are on the side of the road staring at a smoking engine while wondering how on Earth they ended up where they are.
Year three is always a critical one for a new coach, and this year’s results could determine whether or not another large hiring class is ushered in before the 2016 season.
Steve Addazio, Boston College (14-12, 8-8 ACC): Addazio has posted matching records of 7-6 overall and 4-4 in ACC play in each of his two seasons, though through different methods. His 2013 Eagles leaned heavily on Heisman Trophy finalist Andre Williams, while last year’s bunch incorporated the running ability of Florida quarterback transfer Tyler Murphy. Either way, Addazio’s teams have fit well with the BC mold: a team that probably won’t compete for a championship but – as Florida State saw in November – will be a tough out every single week.
Dave Doeren, N.C. State (11-14, 3-13 ACC): After a 3-9 reboot year, Doeren’s club rebounded to win the St. Petersburg Bowl in year two while joining the gaggle of teams to get a few jabs in on Florida State before the ‘Noles responded with a haymaker. The 2014 Wolfpack’s eight wins came against its eight worst opponent and its five losses came by the hands of the five best. Instead of enjoying life in the wide-open Coastal, Doeren must gear N.C. State up to compete in a division with Florida State, Clemson and Louisville.
Scott Shafer, Syracuse (10-15, 5-11): Shafer’s two seasons have diverged completely from Doeren’s, as the Orange won the Texas Bowl in his debut and then fell to 3-9 (1-7 ACC) in 2014. Heading into the always-critical year three, Shafer needs a big year.
Kliff Kingsbury, Texas Tech (12-13, 6-12 Big 12): They said there’d be a learning curve for Kingsbury’s first two years as a head coach and, well, they were right. After winning his first seven games back home in Lubbock, Kingsbury closed the 2013 regular season by losing five straight before rebounding with an inspiring Holiday Bowl blowout of Arizona State. Perhaps the biggest head scratcher thus far has been at his signature position – quarterback – which has been a revolving door of injuries, inconsistent play and transfers.
Darrell Hazell, Purdue (4-20, 1-15 Big Ten): Hazell has won four games in two full seasons. The man Purdue fired to hire him, Danny Hope, won six in his final season. Needless to say, that’s not the ratio Purdue had in mind.
Sonny Dykes, California (6-18, 3-15 Pac-12): Year one was a culture shock, for sure, though that’s to be expected when moving from Ruston, La., to Berkeley. Year two was more of what one expects from a Sonny Dykes team, as the win total jumped by four and the overall competition level grew by leaps and bounds. As depth continues to improve, look for the Bears to break though to the postseason in 2015.
Mark Helfrich, Oregon (24-4, 15-3 Pac-12): Helfrich has filled the void left by Chip Kelly admirably, putting his stamp on the program while never once looking insecure in himself and his abilities. Now he gets to prove once again he can win without a brilliant talent, except this time it’s the guy under center that’s leaving.
Mike MacIntyre, Colorado (6-18, 1-17 Pac-12): Like Dykes, Mike Mac got off to a tough start but his team showed improvement last year.
Bret Bielema, Arkansas (10-15, 2-14 SEC): Never has a 2-14 mark looked more threatening. The Razorbacks posted back-to-back shutouts of LSU and Ole Miss and played Alabama, Mississippi State, Texas A&M and Missouri to within one score. As imposing as the Arkansas offense can be once the offensive line gets the backs running downhill, consider this stat: the Hogs allowed a total of 45 points in their final five games.
Butch Jones, Tennessee (12-13, 5-11 SEC): Tennessee may not quite be ready to play for an SEC championship in 2015, but the all-important narrative sees a wide-open SEC East and wonders why the Vols can’t find their way to Atlanta. There’s a lot of talent in Knoxville to be sure, but let’s remember this is a roster that’s 1-11 against ranked foes heading into this fall.
Gus Malzahn, Auburn (20-7, 11-5 SEC): The memorable run to the 2013 SEC championship and national title game (deservedly) grabs the top bullet point, but if I’m an Auburn fan it’s the loss to Alabama last year that encourages me most. Malzahn proved he can walk into Tuscaloosa and put the Tide on its heels even when he’s not throwing his best stuff. Now add a Will Muschamp defense to the mix and see what happens.
Mark Stoops (7-17, 2-14 SEC): Stoops and AD Mitch Barnhart have successfully upped the ante in recruiting, in facilities, and in overall attitude. Kentucky no longer behaves like a basketball school dallying in football, instead like a major athletics department that wants to be really good in both. After a season in which his Wildcats started 5-1 and ended 5-7, it’s time Stoops’ on-field product matches everything else.
Tommy Tuberville, Cincinnati (18-8, 13-3 American): This is right in line with what was expected when Tuberville abruptly left Texas Tech for Cincinnati, keeping the Bearcats in contention for conference titles while not bolting for a bigger program – yet. As for securing Cincinnati a spot in the ACC? Still waiting on that one.
Willie Taggart, South Florida (6-18, 5-11 American): What seemed like a perfect match on paper has not turned out that way in real life. A successful head coach, a talented recruiter with a magnetic personality that happens to be from the Tampa area taking over USF? What could be better? The Taggart era started with a stumble – a 53-21 loss to FCS McNeese State – and still hasn’t found its footing.
Matt Rhule, Temple (8-16, 5-11 American): A near identical record as Taggart, but Rhule’s two seasons have inspired a completely different feel. After a 2-10 debut, Temple posted a bowl-eligible 6-6 mark in 2014 with close losses to Navy, Memphis and Cincinnati while playing some of the country’s best defense. The Owls are a team to watch in 2015.
Ron Caragher, San Jose State (9-15, 7-9 MW): Caragher took over a team that went 10-2 and cracked the top 25 the year prior, and has since seen the Spartans’ win total drop to six and then three.
Brian Polian, Nevada (11-14, 7-9 MW): The running game is no longer among the top 10 in the nation, but Polian has kept the ship steady. A 4-8 debut season was answered with a 7-6 finish and a bowl trip in 2014.
Matt Wells, Utah State (19-9, 13-3 MW): Just imagine what this guy could do if he could get a quarterback to say healthy. After sharing a Mountain West title in year one, Wells won 10 games in 2014 while navigating a season in which he had to play four different quarterbacks. Heading to year three, though, the question will be if Wells can sustain that level of success with offensive coordinator Kevin McGiven gone for Oregon State and only the remains of Gary Andersen’s recruits still in Logan.
Skip Holtz, Louisiana Tech (13-13, 10-6 C-USA): It may have not worked out at South Florida, but Holtz knows how to win in Conference USA. After winning C-USA titles in each of his final two seasons at East Carolina, Holtz jumped back into the league and claimed the C-USA West Division crown in year two at Louisiana Tech. Now, will his Bulldogs look like last year’s 9-5 team or the 4-8 team of 2013 without defensive coordinator Manny Diaz leading a unit that produced an FBS-best 42 turnovers?
Sean Kugler, UTEP (9-16, 6-10 C-USA): Don’t let the record fool you, Kugler has the Miners heading in the right direction. UTEP jumped five wins from 2013 to 2014 and held fourth quarter leads over Texas Tech and Western Kentucky last year.
Todd Monken, Southern Miss (4-20, 2-14 C-USA): How could arguably the nation’s most consistent mid-major go through a stretch where it wins only two conference games in 24 tries? Did Larry Fedora forget to leave behind the answer key or something? Whatever the reason, Monken needs to find some answers in 2015.
Ron Turner, Florida International (5-19, 4-12 C-USA): What can we say? This was a curious hire by AD Pete Garcia at the time, and it hasn’t looked much better in the two seasons since. Turner did bump the Panthers’ win total by three from 2013 to 2014, but now he and his staff must deal with Charlie Partridge in the battle for South Florida’s recruits.
Rod Carey, Northern Illinois (23-6, 15-1 MAC): Like Helfrich, Rod Carey has demonstrated how a passing-of-the-torch should go at a successful program. But unlike Helfrich, Carey has already posted an 11-win season and a conference championship without his franchise quarterback.
P.J. Fleck, Western Michigan (9-16, 7-9 MAC): Among coaches taking over struggling programs, no one in his hiring class has performed the reboot-and-reload better than Fleck. The first-time head coach sling-shot his Broncos from 1-11 in year one to 8-5 in year two, with eyes on the program’s first bowl win in year three.
Paul Haynes, Kent State (6-17, 4-11 MAC): Kent State hasn’t fared any better without Hazell than Hazell has without Kent State. Under a first-time head coach in Haynes, the Flashes have fallen from 11 wins in 2012 to four in 2013 and then two in 2014.
Doug Martin, New Mexico State (4-20, 1-7 Sun Belt): If there’s one school on this list where a 4-20 beginning should be met with patience, patience and more patience, it’s New Mexico State.
Trent Miles, Georgia State (1-23, 0-15 Sun Belt): It’s hard to say where the problem lies, but heading into year three without an FBS victory was not part of the plan. Especially in the most talent-rich area of the conference and while another school with the same initials downstate already has more Sun Belt championships than Georgia State has Sun Belt victories.
Paul Petrino, Idaho (2-21, 1-7 Sun Belt): Perhaps we’re biting more than we can chew in one paragraph but with Idaho – and perhaps the two preceding programs – perhaps the school should question if it’s in the right subdivision before it questions if it has the right coaching staff.
Scott Satterfield, Appalachian State (11-13, 6-2 Sun Belt): Don’t let what happened last season at Georgia Southern fool you, this is how an FBS transition is supposed to go. Improving from 4-8 in a farewell-to-FCS to a 6-2 Sun Belt debut is a great sign for Satterfield and his staff.
Nick Saban told a story about catching a 180 pound fish, and Twitter went bonkers
Down at the SEC meetings in Destin, Florida earlier today, Nick Saban opened up time in front of the press with a story about how he recently reeled in a fish that was six feet long and weighed about as much as he does at 180 pounds.
Saban lamented that the monster took them about an hour to reel in, which he believes is some kind of record.
The fun started once people started to tweet out that opening story because – in the name of good fun – the Twitterverse had apparently been waiting for a moment like this from Saban for years.
— SB Nation (@SBNation) May 26, 2015
Saban on the fish: “I hung in there. It’s called mental toughness.” — Andy Staples (@Andy_Staples) May 26, 2015
Saban said he caught an 180-pound fish this weekend. (It will not count towards Alabama’s 85.)
— Seth Emerson (@SethEmersonAJC) May 26, 2015
Big time breaking news here. Saban’s probably wondering if that fish can rush the passer. https://t.co/KJI3SUO2IL
— Danny Crawford (@dannycrawford30) May 26, 2015
When there are about 100 days until college football kicks off again, this kind of stuff is highly entertaining.
#TakeASide: Should a new coordinator adopt your existing terminology, or bring his own?
While out on his off season speaking tour of Georgia, Mark Richt spent some time talking about his new offensive coordinator, Brian Schottenheimer. Schottenheimer, who has nine years of coordinating experience in the NFL, takes over for Mike Bobo, who previously held the offensive coordinator title under Richt dating back to 2007, before taking the Colorado State head coaching job this past off season.
“Coach Schottenheimer has been hired to coordinate the offense, and call the game, so it’s important for whoever is calling the game to have a comfort level with what he is about to say. One of the reasons we hired coach Schottenheimer is because, philosophically, he likes to do what we do and what we’ve been doing.”
“We like to run the football, we like to play action pass, and we want to be able to spread it out and throw it as good as anyone in America,” Richt explained. “We do have a few new things terminology wise, but concept wise it’s almost identical.”
Richt brings up a really good point about wanting his play caller to have a certain comfort level. But a lot of other head coaches in the profession believe in what lies on the other side of the coin; if you bring in a new coordinator, and decide to use the same terminology that you’ve used in the past, only one person (the new coordinator) has to learn a new system, and the other 50, or 70, or 100 guys on the roster don’t have to learn a bunch of new terminology.
There are valid points to each side, so I’m going to ask you to pick a side, and defend your opinion in the comments below, or via Twitter (@CoachSamz). For the sake of the argument, let’s assume you’re bringing in a new coordinator after your previous one spent four seasons with you.
Side 1: The new coordinator adopts your previous terminology
In this situation, you decide on a new coordinator, and instead of having your entire team and coaching staff learn a new system, you have your new hire adopt your previous terminology and try to hit the ground running.
Pros: Your team and coaching staff retain a sense of consistency with the previous system.
Cons: Your play caller on game day has to learn a whole new system from what he’s accustomed to.
Side 2: You allow your new coordinator to bring his own terminology and system
This is more along the Mark Richt train of thought. You want your coordinator to feel comfortable calling plays on game day, so you allow him to bring his own system, complete with his own set of concepts and terminology. This means that your coaching staff and your entire roster dig into a new playbook so that everyone can get on the same page.
Pro: The new coordinator has an immediate sense of comfort in his new surroundings and has a command for the system, which could really help with the learning curve with players and the staff.
Cons: Your coaching staff and entire roster have to get up to speed with a new system and new terminology, which could easily set you back a step or two from where you want to be.
There are a lot of other variables to consider (for example, you wouldn’t bring in a proven guy like Will Muschamp and ask him to adopt your system), but at face value, where do you stand?
Over the next few weeks, we’ll take a look at a number of issues like this that divide the coaching profession and get your input, and share it with the rest of the profession. Have an idea on the next issue we should tackle? Send suggestions to email@example.com or via twitter @CoachSamz.
— C. John Chavis (@CJohnChavis) May 26, 2015
@CoachSamz New OC’s should bring/use their own system/terminology………if not, why hire them.
— Mike Burns (@coachmikeburns) May 26, 2015
— Travis Hawk (@TravisHawk44) May 26, 2015
Iowa State AD Jamie Pollard has the perfect response to coaching rumors
Everyone who’s anyone in the NBA says the Chicago Bulls are planning on firing head coach Tom Thibodeau, and most in the know claim Iowa State’s Fred Hoiberg will be the Bulls’ choice to replace him.
Hoiberg, affectionately dubbed “The Mayor” during his playing days as a Cyclone and named by this site as the best tweeter among college head coaches, is 115-56 in five seasons with his alma mater. After a 16-16 debut, Hoiberg has guided the Cyclones to four straight NCAA tournaments and two straight Big 12 tournament titles.
Obviously, losing Hoiberg to the NBA would be less than ideal for Iowa State. It’s also inevitable.
A smart, successful 42-year-old college coach with 10 years of experience in the NBA just isn’t going to slip under the association’s radar forever. Especially not with former Butler head coach Brad Stevens’s success with the Boston Celtics.
If you’re Iowa State athletics director Jamie Pollard, what do you do? You call every booster in your phone book and try to make it as hard as possible for Hoiberg to leave, sure. But you also can’t stop a guy from living his dream, either.
So here, via the Ames Tribune, is how Pollard addressed the situation to a group of Cyclones fans:
“I think everyone needs to take a step away from the ledge. I recognize it’s tough on (the media), it’s tough on the players, it’s tough on fans. At the end of the day, Fred has done a tremendous amount for our institution and the last five years has been pretty special.
“What the future holds, I don’t have that answer. That’s a personal decision he’s got to make and it’s complicated. I think he’s earned the right to be able to deal with it how he sees fit.”
He didn’t plug his fingers into his ears and close his eyes. He didn’t blame Hoiberg or the Bulls or the media. Instead, Pollard treated his head coach and his fans like adults.
Here’s hoping more ADs and head coaches follow his lead this winter.
Video: Have you ever seen an ambidextrous trick shot kicker?
Kicking field goals with your dominant leg is no easy task for the average Joe.
Well Central Florida commit Donald Delahaye is anything but average. Watch him here as he gets two balls to spin vertically without using his hands, and then proceeds to nail a field goal of about 20 or 30 yards – all without the help of anyone else.
Have you ever seen anything like this? Unreal.